i don't want even to begin to address ed owens'
wonderfully provocative question about offesnvely
provocative films [or other materials] used in a
classroom setting . . . i simply want to suggest
tht while sudent sensibilities must obviously be
a central consideration for anyone who takes
teaching seriously, ANY answer to ed's question will
inevitably have repurcussions for other areas in
which student sensibilities might be at risk . . .
specifically: what do we do about issues such
as evolution with students whose religious beliefs
make such issues offensive? . . . similarly, may we
talk about freud to students whose lives include
a serious investment in the notion of soul? . . . and
how about teaching gay lit or film to those who
find the very idea an abomination? . . .
i'm not sure i see how we can readily distinguish
between teaching gay materials to the homophobic
on the one hand and teaching sexually explicit
materials to the prudish on the other . . . at
some point sensitivity or "political correctness"
comes into conflict with academic freedom and
intellectual integrity . . .
so what do we do? . . . this is a much more complex
problem than ed's apparently innocent question seems
>===== Original Message From Film and TV Studies Discussion List
<[log in to unmask]> =====
>From: Ed Owens <drsloomis@
>>Subject: ...Too Provocative... (was Re: VOYeuRISM Assistance)
>This brings up an interesting question, specifically for those that teach
>film. Are your film selections guided by a consideration for the
>sensibilities of your intended audience? One time in particular, I was
>approached by a student at the beginning of the semester and informed of
>aversion to anything R-rated. I worked with the student to come up with
>alternative films for the three in question, but wonder to what extent this
>sort of practice should be employed. I'd be interested in hearing of
>with similar experiences and how you handled them, as well as what your
>feelings are towards providing alternatives (or even designing the class
>around such issues in the first place).
>To sign off Screen-L, e-mail [log in to unmask] and put SIGNOFF Screen-L
>in the message. Problems? Contact [log in to unmask]
To sign off Screen-L, e-mail [log in to unmask] and put SIGNOFF Screen-L
in the message. Problems? Contact [log in to unmask]