>> you could argue that, for instance, because the camera >> is pointed at Henry Hill several times in GOODFELLAS, we >> are not seeing the action through his eyes . . . > As my hurried and meagre contribution to this debate, let me simply point out that Francois Truffaut believed that the true subjective camera was provided by a close-up, not a point-of-view shot. He is also the filmmaker who used voice-over more often and more resourcefully than any other major filmmaker, and, of course, he is the filmmaker who made "cinema in the first person singular." Gene Walz University of Manitoba ---- Online resources for film/TV studies may be found at ScreenSite http://www.sa.ua.edu/screensite