Print

Print


 Rick Schott <[log in to unmask]> wrote:
 
>I'm not going to pretend that I've read lots of research on this subject, =
but..
>
>1)  It sounds like this experiment might only prove that watching violent
>television leads one to engage in violent _play_.  This does not mean that
>those same children would engage in real violent behaviour towards each
>other.  In other word, watching images of violence might just expand their
>ability to make-believe violence, not to really enact it. For adults, an
>analogous example: a person might watch a porno in which depicts somewhat
>violent sex.  That adult might engage in violent sexual fantasies, or even
>make-believe violent SM, but not _actually_ have truly violent, harmful
>sex.
>(This is just speculation based on how you presented the finding of the
>experiment -- perhaps the children _did_ become more violent towards each
>other).
>
>2)  I have heard that Japan's television has more depictions of violence
>than US televison, and yet the violent crime rate is much lower in Japan.
>Is this an academic version of an "urban myth" or does someone have an
>actual citation for this claim?  If so, how does this impact our current
>discussion?
>
 
1. You've just summarized one of the main criticisms against media effects=
=20
research. And, from the research available - which is A LOT - no one has be=
en=20
able to answer that question convincingly. Even if some researchers claims =
there=20
is an undisputable causal link between media violence and real-life violenc=
e, I=20
find these claims more the result of belief than of hard-core empiric resul=
ts.=20
You want to believe films cause violence? Go ahead, there's loads of studie=
s=20
supporting your view.=20
You don't think so? Go ahead, there's loads of studies supporting your view.
 
2. True. I can't find references right now, but Japanese TV (and comics and=
=20
films) are probably more obsessed with violence than anywhere else around t=
he=20
world. And their rime levels are very low. What we mustn't forget is that=20
Japanese culture is a lot more hierarchic and puts more emphasis on self-co=
ntrol=20
than western societies. What can we learn from this? That cultural factors=
=20
influence the levels of violence in a society a lot more than media images.=
 (But=20
then again, there could be even lover levels of violence in Japan if the me=
dia=20
weren't so violent... we'll never know.
 
Ulf
Ulf Dalquist                Phone:  +46 46 2224266
Dept. of Sociology          Fax:    +46 46 2224794
Box 114 221 00 Lund SWEDEN  E-mail: [log in to unmask]        =20
"You hear about 'constitutional rights', 'free speech', and the 'free press=
'. Every time I hear these words I say to myself, 'That man is a Red!!...' =
You never hear a real American talk like that!"
                                                                                                                                                                               Mayor Frank Hague, Jersey City
 
----
To signoff SCREEN-L, e-mail [log in to unmask] and put SIGNOFF SCREEN-L
in the message.  Problems?  Contact [log in to unmask]