----------------------------Original message---------------------------- >Simply because of the huge volume of material, I'm sure there's more >right than wrong in The Motion Picture Guide. I'd be interested in >knowing whether the material published in the book edition and its >yearbook-updates has been revised for CD-ROM, or if it's all simply >been digitized and reconfigured for electronic reading. > >Perhaps James might take it on himself to look up Greenberg's review, >use it as a basis for a little test, and offer a little more critical >review as part of the Consumer Reports corner of SCREEN-L. > >Blaine Allan [log in to unmask] Yes, I will try to find the FQ article and am willing to do a thorough test of the disc. I have found some mistakes, and the critisim is not fourth year film dissection. But (sadly) compared to what is available, it's the best around. But I will look into and use it some more :-) James