As the executive director of a national group of film critics I became embroiled in the controversy initiated when the MPAA gave "Henry and June" an X rating. We can speculate all we want in academia, but Valenti is not very budgeable. My critics recommended a rating that was for adults but did not have the stigma of X (the only uncopyrighted category, which is therefore exploited). This is not a major threat but Valenti got very defensive. liz weis