Well, if I understand the principles of screen-l, it says somewhere something about "discussions" pertaining to film and television. I am sorry to say that of late, I have not seen much "discussion" taking place but instead a sort of exchange of cooking recipes, limited knowledge, insufficient data. What Louis (S) was doing was about the only thing close to a discussion I have seen on the system. It seems that we all are too often satisfied with the sort of polite one way exchanges that abound in our classes and retreat to the air-raid shelter as soon as voices are raised and people actually hold antithetical positions. Mind you, I am not for an all-out verbal war but who are we kidding? Do we care so little about the field that there is no passions left around? If people want to have a really good go at each other, let's have it. I would rather read that than the endless list of queries, film lists (usually exclusively anglo-titles) and incomplete book titles, followed by two hundred opinions, rectifications and endless rewordings that have characterized Screen-l of late. There is a very big difference between a moderated list and a censored one.