As there is perhaps an interesting debate emerging about methodologies and the practice of 'close analysis' in particular, and further to Warren Buckland's recent posting of his review of the above-mentioned book to Screen-L, I thought list members might be interested in Clayton and Klevan's response, which I recently came across via Twitter: http://bristol.academia.edu/AlexClayton/Papers/1946470/Authors_Reply_to_War ren_Bucklands_Review_of_The_Language_and_Style_of_Film_Criticism Dr. Tom Brown, Lecturer in Film Film Studies Department King's College London Norfolk Building Strand Campus London WC2R 2LS Tel: 020 7848 2018 ---- Learn to speak like a film/TV professor! Listen to the ScreenLex podcast: http://www.screenlex.org