Maybe we should hold our own version? People can submit their favourite
films and actors in the various categories and the most popular are
submitted to the group for voting. The results are then collated and posted
around Academy Awards time.
Just an idea - it would be interesting to compare!
a lovely idea . . . is it practicable? . . . if there's a way of
negotiating it i think we oughta go for it, if only to see how
it comes out . . . though, coming from a bunch of ostensible
"experts," it might earn some public recognition, our
culture being so obsessed with ratings and lists . .
but i wonder about one thing: should it be our "favorite
films and actors" or the ones we admire/respect/value
most highly . . . i would hardly want to call BOYS DON'T
CRY my "favorite" film of the year but it seems to me
a remarkable achievement . . . while OTOH, i often have
"favorite" films, books, music that i recognize as not
especially distinguished but which speak to me for very
personal reasons . . . i think we're in a position to make
informed as opposed to purely intuitive judgments, and
if the logistics of this can be worked out that's the
path i'd like to see us take . . . but just how do we manage
the logistics? . . . any thoughts from screen-L'ers or the
For past messages, visit the Screen-L Archives: