I forgot to actually answer Gloria's question in my last posting. Wollen goes on to say, "It remains an endearing irony that, in reality, if I can so use the phrase, Debbie Reynolds's singing voice in the film was in fact dubbed by Jean Hagen, so that what we see and hear is the unveiling of a mystery which subverts its own appearance of authenticity." (p. 56, SINGIN' IN THE RAIN, London: BFI, 1992). So there you have it. Kelley